Employee benefits are a massive part of total compensation—if yours are misaligned, you might be overspending without seeing appropriate returns. Here are five telling signs your benefits strategy may be costing you—and how the numbers back it up:

1. Health Benefits Costs Are Rising—And Fast

• Average family coverage premiums are now $25,572 per year, rising 7% in 2024. For single coverage, it’s $8,951 annually. KFF
• 2025 projections show cost-per-employee health benefits rising 5.8% even after cost-control measures; without those, it could increase by ~7%. Smaller firms may face hikes near 9%. MercerReutersHealthcare Dive
• Another forecast by Aon projects average healthcare cost increases of up to 9.2% next year—10.3% for small employers—bringing total per-employee costs above $16,000. AonSHRM
• For a family of four, total annual health-insurance costs now exceed $35,000, nearly tripling over the past 20 years. Axios

Takeaway: If your health benefits costs are rising or exceeding these benchmarks, that’s a clear signal to reevaluate.

2. Benefits Eat Up a Third (or More) of Total Compensation

• Across industries, benefits account for 29–31% of total compensation. In 2025, that’s about $13.49 per hour, or a 42.3% labor burden rate—meaning you spend 42¢ on benefits for every dollar in wages. Capital ServicesKSJB AM 600
• In private industry: ~$12.06/hr (~29.6%) on benefits, with about $1,929.60 per month per employee. Care.comthepayrollshoppe.com

Takeaway: Spending significantly above 30% of compensation on benefits might be pushing your overhead too high.

3. Employees Don’t Use—or Understand—Their Benefits

• A notable 85% of employees say they’re confused by their benefits details, yet 87% value health insurance, 72% dental, and 63% mental health benefits. thepayrollshoppe.com
• Without clarity, engagement dips—and unused benefits still cost money.

Takeaway: If adoption or understanding of your benefits is low, you’re paying for silent value.

4. Absenteeism and Poor Health Habits Are Inflating Costs

• Absenteeism alone costs U.S. employers an average $660 per employee annually. And unhealthy employees cost up to $1,601 more per year each in lost productivity. Wikipedia
• For every $1 spent on workplace health promotion, employers save around $3.27 in healthcare costs and $2.73 in absenteeism costs. Wikipedia
• Meanwhile, employee burnout can cost companies between $4,000 to $21,000 per employee per year. For a 1,000-person company, that’s about a $5 million annual drag. Reddit

Takeaway: If health-related losses or burnout are high, your benefits may be costing more than you’re saving.

5. You’re Missing High-ROI Benefits That Pay Off Big

• Childcare benefits (stipends, on-site care, backup care) can deliver a 425% ROI by boosting retention and productivity—and reducing costs tied to turnover. Business Insider
• Employers offering financial-wellness perks like strong 401(k) matches, student loan assistance, or emergency savings programs can drive significant employee loyalty and reduce stress. Capital Services

Takeaway: If your benefits are heavy on cost but light on ROI, you’re missing opportunities.

Summary Table: Cost vs Impact

Next Steps: What You Can Do

1. Benchmark your costs: Compare your health premiums, benefit mix, and compensation burden against industry averages.
2. Measure engagement: Survey employees to gauge understanding and utilization of benefits.
3. Track hidden costs: Quantify absenteeism, burnout, and health-related productivity losses.
4. Introduce high-ROI benefits: Consider childcare support, financial wellness tools, or health promotion programs.
5. Communicate better: Clear, accessible benefit education drives engagement—and ensures value.

Final Thoughts

If your benefits costs are climbing faster than ~6% annually, taking up more than 30–40% of total compensation, or underutilized by employees, it’s time to reassess. Leveraging data—and smarter benefit choices—can transform your strategy from cost center to competitive advantage.

 Let’s Benchmark Your Current Benefits (It’s Free!)

Schedule your analysis with one of our key HR benefits experts now:
800.922.4133
 Visit our benefits options now